Skip to content
Hogfish Bar & Grill logo
A spread of Hogfish Bar & Grill dishes, fried whole snapper, the Killer Hogfish Sandwich, fish and chips, and Baja-style tacos

OUR MENU

Tucked away on the shrimp docks of Stock Island, we’re the worst-kept secret in town, where locals meet, fishermen eat, and seafood lovers find their happy place. Known for serving up some of the best seafood in Key West, we have it all! From just-caught hogfish to dockside favorites, our menu’s got the flavor of the Keys written all over it.

Come hungry. We SEAfood and we eat it!

ISLAND FAVORITES

  • Bahamian Conch Salad Ceviché - 21

  • Spicy Mexican SHRIMP CEVICHE - 22

    with Fresh Avocado & Chips

  • Fresh Local Key West Pink Shrimp

    Maryland Style “Old Bay” Spiced & Chilled. . . or BEER-STEAMED!

    Half Pound - 24 / One Pound - 34

  • Royal Red Shrimp

    Ask your Server about our Royal Red Shrimp

ALL-TIME LOCAL FAVORITES

  • SHRIMP & Chips - 24

  • HOGFISH & Chips - 24

  • CHICKEN & Chips - 21

SOUPS & CHOWDERS

  • Chef’s Soup of the Day - 8

  • Bahamian Conch Chowder - 13

  • Our Famous Lobster Bisque - 14

  • Seriously Overloaded CHILI - 12

APPETIZERS

  • Killer TUNA NACHOS - 27

  • Crispy-Fried Bang-Bang SHRIMP - 21

  • Coconut or Buffalo SHRIMP - 21

  • Local Florida Keys Smoked FISH DIP - 19

  • The Famous HOGFISH FINGERS - 18

    From our Local Fish Market

  • Fried CALAMARI Rings - 18

  • Killer CONCH FRITTERS - 15

  • CHICKEN QUESADILLA - 19

    with Sautéd Onions & Peppers

    Add Shrimp - 9

  • Chef JR’s Island FISH CAKES - 20

    Served with House Remoulade Sauce

  • El NACHO GRANDE - 20

    Add Grilled Chicken - 7 | Shrimp or Pork - 9

  • Crispy ONION RINGS

    Small - 9 / Regular - 12

FRESH SALADS

  • Stock Island COBB Salad - 23

    with Key West Gulf Shrimp, Bacon, Onions, Hard Boiled Egg & Bleu Cheese Crumbles

  • Island SUMMER Salad - 24

    Arugula, Mandarins, Dried Cranberries, Pecans, Goat Cheese, Cherry Tomatoes & Cucumbers, topped with Blackened Shrimp

  • House Salad - 10

  • Great CAESAR Salad - 16

Make your Salad DELUXE by adding SHRIMP, HOGFISH, SCALLOPS ($9) or CHICKEN ($7)

OUR DESSERTS

  • Award-Winning Key Lime Pie
  • Homemade Piña Colada Bread Pudding
  • Local Favorite Coconut Flan

OUR LEGENDARY PARTY WINGS

FAMOUS JAMAICAN JERK, GARLIC PARMESAN, or CLASSIC BUFFALO - 23

STOCK ISLAND SHRIMP BOIL SUNDAYS ONLY!

Local Gulf Shrimp, Smoked Sausage, Corn & Potatoes. Served with Cornbread - 34

LEGENDARY BURGERS

All burgers are served with fries.

  • Jimmy’s Double Smashburger in Paradise - 23

    Sirloin, Brisket & Chuck blended fresh DAILY, topped with Onions, Mushrooms & Melted Cheese

  • The Killer Birria Burger - 23

    Smothered in spicy, shredded Birra Meat & Swiss Cheese

  • The Big “VANDENBURGER” - 26

    The BIGGEST & BEST BURGER in the Keys, a special blend of Sirloin, Brisket & Chuck made fresh DAILY. Served with Onions, Mushrooms & Melted Cheese.

BIG ‘OL SANDWICHES

All sandwiches are served with fries.

  • Bobby’s GROUPER REUBEN - 24

    with Thousand Island Dressing & Cole Slaw

  • Fried KW LOBSTER BLT - 27

    on a Fresh Brioche Bun, with Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato

  • NOLA’s SHRIMP PO’ BOY - 23

    with Spicy Remoulade Sauce

  • Spicy Honey-Fried CHICKEN - 22

    Served with Crispy Onion Rings & Sweet Pickle

  • Philly STEAK & CHEESE - 21

    with Onions & Peppers

  • The Best CUBAN Mix in Town - 16

  • Southern Soul PULLED PORK - 20

  • Fresh HOGFISH Sliders - 20

    Two Sliders with Key Lime Tartar Sauce & Pico de Gallo

  • Smothered CHILI DOGS - 15

    dressed all the way with Onion Rings

STOCK ISLAND DINNERS

If you’re HUNGRY, bring it on!

  • Stock Island Shrimp & Grits - 33

    with Stone-Ground Cheesy Grits, Andouille Sausage, Peppers & Onions. Served with Cornbread

    Add Hogfish - 9

  • Fried WHOLE SNAPPER - 36

    Local Delicacy served with Fries & Slaw

  • CRABMEAT Stuffed HOGFISH - 38

    with Island Rice, Veggies & Mango Cream Sauce

  • Stock Island MIXED GRILL - 38

    Fresh Local Fish, Shrimp, Scallops & Lobster with Island Rice, Veggies, Grilled Onions & Peppers

  • SURF & TURF - 40

    Marinated Skirt Steak with Shrimp or Scallops

  • Grilled YELLOWTAIL Snapper - 38

    with Blackened Scallops, Rice & Veggies

  • LOBSTER & Key West SHRIMP MAC & CHEESE - 35

    Three Cheeses, Macaroni & Toasted Bread Crumbs. Served with Cornbread

  • Local Catch FAJITAS - 35

    with Sautéed Onions, Peppers & Homemade Pico de Gallo

    Add Shrimp - 9

  • Fried GROUPER DINNER - 35

    Blackend or Grilled, with Mashed Potatoes & Veggies

  • Chicken TERIYAKI Dinner - 25

    with Roasted Pineapple, Provolone, Mashed Potatoes & Veggies

  • Classic Havana ROAST PORK - 29

    Local Favorite with Rice, Black Beans, Plantains & Cuban Bread

  • Blackened MAHI MAHI - 32

    Served with Island Rice & Fresh Vegetables

Download Dinner Menu (PDF)

You can also read the dinner and drinks menus as text on this page.

Ask your server about gluten-free options. Check our blackboard for today’s specials. Thank the kitchen staff with a round of beers – $10.

We are glad to COOK YOUR CATCH (Filets only, Fried Blackened or Grilled) with 2 Sides of your choice... for just $19/pound/person! Add $8 per additional pound.

AmEx, Visa, MC & Discover accepted. No separate checks, please. Due to rising credit card fee costs, a 3% processing fee is added to all credit card purchases. A $1 additional charge applies to all to-go dinners. 20% gratuity on parties of 6 or more.

*Consumer advisory: Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodbourne illness.

Dragonfruit Mojito

DRINK LIKE A LOCAL

From ice-cold beers to tropical cocktails with a salty twist, we’re pouring the good stuff daily. Kick back, sip slow, and toast to island time.

Drink Menu

TACOS WITH A LOCAL TWIST

Whether you're into crispy Hogfish, juicy chicken, spicy shrimp, blackened tuna, tender birria, or local lobster, we’ve got a taco with your name on it. These Baja-style beauties bring big island flavor in every bite.

THE BEST BAJA STYLE TACOS IN THE KEYS!

  • HOGFISH Tacos - 24**

  • SHRIMP Tacos - 23**

  • CHICKEN Tacos - 21**

  • BLACKENED TUNA Tacos - 22**

  • Mexican BIRRIA Tacos - 21

  • FRIED KW LOBSTER Tacos - 25

  • Havana PORK Tacos - 21

**Blackened, grilled or fried. Served with rice and beans.

Our famous Baja-style tacos with yellow rice, black beans, and chips

DRINKS

SPECIALTY COCKTAILS

SHAKEN & STIRRED

  • Keys’ APEROL SPRITZ - 12

    Prosecco, Aperol with an Orange Wedge on the Rocks

  • Hogfish BLOODY MARY - 18

    Tito’s Vodka & Charleston Bloody Mix, loaded with Key West Pink Shrimp, Bacon and a Tajin Rim

  • The ATOCHA GOLD Margarita - 15

    Herradura Reposado Tequila, Fresh Lime, Cointreau, Sour Mix, splash of OJ & Grand Marnier Float

  • The Bahama Mama ••• LOCAL FAVE ••• - 15

    Capt. Morgan Spiced Rum, Bacardi Rum, OJ, Pineapple Juice, Coco Lopez, Pomegranate Liqueur Float topped with Shaved Coconut soaked in Havana Club Rum

  • Nauti Nut Colada - 15

    Nauti Beach Coconut Rum, Coco Lopez, Pineapple Juice with Toasted Coconut

  • Stock Island Pink Lemonade - 15

    Muddled Lemon, Absolut Citron, Simple Syrup, Dragonfruit with Sour Mix

  • Dragonfruit Mojito - 15

    Parrot Bay Key Lime Rum, Fresh Muddled Lime, Dragonfruit, Simple Syrup & Mint

  • The Drunken Hogfish - 15

    Light & Dark Rum, Coconut Rum, Orange & Pineapple Juices with Grenadine and a 151 Float

  • The Classic Bulleit Old Fashioned - 18

    Bulleit Straight Bourbon, Simple Syrup, Aromatic Bitters, stirred on the Rocks with an Orange Wedge

  • Sex On The Dock - 15

    Three Olive Orange Vodka, Peach Schnapps, Pineapple & Cranberry Juices

  • Mezcalita - 18

    Casamigos Jalapeño & Mezcal Tequilas, with Cointreau, Sour Mix and Splash of Orange Juice

  • La Paloma Rosada - 15

    Milagro Reposado with Sparkling Grapefruit Soda & Salted Rim

FROZEN COCKTAILS

$15

  • MANGO COLADA

  • KEY LIME COLADA

  • PIÑA COLADA

  • STRAWBERRY DAIQUIRI

  • MUDSLIDE

  • MANGO DAIQUIRI

SPARKLING WINES

  • Cinzano, PROSECCO, Italy - 10/30

  • Rotari, Brut ROSÉ, Italy (split) - 11

  • Laurent-Perrier LA CUVEE BRUT, France - 65

WHITE WINES

  • RIESLING, Clean Slate, Germany - 11/35

  • PINOT GRIGIO, Barone, Italy - 11/32

  • ROSÉ, Studio by Miraval, France - 11/45

  • SAUVIGNON BLANC, Kim Crawford Marlborough - 11/45

  • CHARDONNAY, Annabella, California - 11/42

RED WINES

  • PINOT NOIR, OPP, Oregon - 11/45

  • BLEND, Lapis Luna, California - 11/42

  • CABERNET, Dante, Reserve, California - 11/45

  • CABERNET Markham, Napa Valley - 65

  • MALBEC, Ruta 22, Argentina - 11/42

  • CHIANTI Reserva Ruffino, Italy - 55

HOUSE WINES

$9

COPPER RIDGE CHARDONNAY • MERLOT • CABERNET SAUVIGNON • PINOT GRIGIO

CLASSIC SANGRIA

  • RED or WHITE • Glass - 7

  • Half Carafe - 18

  • Carafe - 30

BREWS ON TAP

  • CRAZY LADY - 6

  • YUENGLING - 6

  • STELLA ARTOIS - 7

  • KEY LIME LAGER - 7

  • HOGFISH RED - 7

  • SEASONAL IPA - 8

DOMESTIC BEERS

  • BUD - 6

  • BUD LIGHT - 6

  • COORS LIGHT - 6

  • MILLER LITE - 6

  • MICHELOB ULTRA - 6

  • SHINER BOCK - 6

  • LAND SHARK - 6

  • ANGRY ORCHARD - 6

IMPORTS

$8

  • HEINEKEN

  • HEINEKEN LIGHT & “0.0”

  • AMSTEL LIGHT

  • CORONA

  • CORONA LIGHT

  • MODELO ESPECIAL

  • MODELO NEGRA

  • RED STRIPE

CAN BEERS

  • PBR 16 Oz. - 4

  • FUNKY BUDDAH WHEAT - 8

  • FOUNDERS ALL DAY IPA - 8

  • GUINNESS 16 Oz. - 8

  • JAI LAI 16 Oz. - 8

  • Assorted WHITE CLAW & HIGH NOON - 7

HOUSE SPECIALTY
HOGFISH SANDWICH

This is the one that put us on the map. Piled high with Swiss, sautéed onions, and mushrooms on fresh Cuban bread, our world-famous Hogfish Sandwich is the real deal. No imposters here, just true, delicate, scallop-like Hogfish every time.

An Incredible Deal for just $25

New to hogfish? Read what makes it special, from reef to plate.

Our fried hogfish sandwich smothered with Swiss cheese, onions and mushrooms, with fries and a pickle